Contributing to Qt 5 epic

Quite some effort goes into Qt 5 in order to push into Qt some of the features which should be in Qt and not in KDE Frameworks. Usually because all Qt apps would benefit from them even outside the KDE world, and because this cuts dependencies between the KDE frameworks.

Once a class is ready to be contributed into Qt, it can also be added to KDE frameworks in libkdeqt5staging/src, for immediate use in kdelibs-frameworks. When we can depend on the Qt5 version that has the class, we can remove it from libkdeqt5staging.

If the addition to Qt is a new method rather than a new class, then an intermediate solution has to be found (possibly with a different API).

Status	Description	Contact
DONE	QStandardPaths	David Faure, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QTemporaryFile (better defaults)	David Faure, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QObject::findChildren(Qt::FindDirectChildrenOnly)	David Faure, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QTemporaryDir	David Faure, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QMimeData: export URLs as plain text too	David Faure, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QCryptographicHash: QIODevice support, to replace KMD5	Sune, in Qt 5.0
DONE	Refcounted quit	Stephen Kelly, change 10408, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QMimeType	David Faure, change 15585, in Qt 5.0
DONE	KUrl/QUrl merge	David Faure and Thiago Macieira (QUrl), in Qt 5.0
DONE	KDebug features into QDebug	Started by Kai Koehne (Nokia) in change 13433, then Wolfgang Beck implemented category logging (13226), and an addon for the API (see QTBUG-19536). Missing API in Qt itself -> 5.1
DONE	Native event filtering in QCoreApplication	David Faure, change 29260, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QSignalSpy::wait (replaces kWaitForSignal)	David Faure, change 30799, in Qt 5.0
DONE	Add app display name to window titles	David Faure, change 42627, in Qt 5.0
DONE	QMainWindow should follow the KDE HIG when changing the window title in a Plasma Workspace session (see KMainWindow::setCaption)	David Faure, commit 92bd9ae in Qt 5.0
DONE	QSaveFile	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/41790), in Qt 5.1
DONE	Add a Q_COREAPP_STARTUP_FUNCTION macro which allows to have code called just at the end of QCoreApplicationPrivate::init()	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/42002), in Qt 5.1
DONE	QDebugStateSaver	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/41793), in Qt 5.1
DONE	K/Q_GLOBAL_STATIC merge	Thiago Macieira (https://codereview.qt-project.org/43297), in Qt 5.1
DONE	qunsetenv	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/44599), in Qt 5.1
DONE	Restore QX11Info, in qtx11extras.git	Richard Moore and David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/45266), in Qt 5.1
DONE	QLockFile	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/46583), in Qt 5.1
DONE	QDebug: coloring the method name (blue for debugs, red for warnings)	Olivier Goffart (https://codereview.qt-project.org/47358), in Qt 5.1
DONE	QKeySequence to/from string	Kévin Ottens, in Qt 5.1
DONE	QMenu: title feature (sections)	Kévin Ottens (https://codereview.qt-project.org/49242), in Qt 5.1
DONE	Create QPA theme plugin for setting KDE palette, font, widget style, etc. (in KDE), will require extensions on the Qt side, look at KGlobalSettings, some of it is there	Kevin Ottens
DONE	Extend QPA theme plugin to use KIconLoader within QIcon::fromTheme()	Kevin Ottens
DONE	QUrl methods to replace the QUrlPathInfo attempt	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/44960)
DONE	QCommandLineParser	Laszlo Papp (initially) / David Faure (now), in Qt 5.2
DONE	contribute natural-comparison to Qt5 (see KStringHandler). In Qt there is naturalCompare function but private and not as good as from KStringHandler. Thiago says: add the feature to QCollator. apol: Figuring out how to use it without ICU. https://qt-project.org/wiki/QCollator https://codereview.qt-project.org/#change,63545	Aleix Pol
DONE	QLineEdit: support for clear button	Kevin Ottens https://codereview.qt-project.org/53155 + https://codereview.qt-project.org/53073
DONE	QTextEdit: support for place holder text like place holder text in QLineEdit	Benjamin Port (https://codereview.qt-project.org/53423)
DONE	Rewrite QKeySequence::StandardKey to get the default keys from QPA, not just an enum. In KDE we can make the shortcuts configurable this way.	David Edmundson
DONE	QTabBar: port signals from KTabBar	Ivan Komissarov (https://codereview.qt-project.org/#change,62415)
DONE	Add the web color line edit to QColorDialog (KColorDialog has it)	David Gil (https://codereview.qt-project.org/53239) in Qt 5.2
DONE	Add the color picker button to QColorDialog (KColorDialog has it)	David Gil (https://codereview.qt-project.org/53242) in Qt 5.2
DONE	QToolBar should take its default settings from the global settings when running in a Plasma Workspace session (see loadKDESettings from KToolBar) https://codereview.qt-project.org/#change,63151 https://git.reviewboard.kde.org/r/112363/	Àlex Fiestas
DONE	QInputDialog should have an equivalent of KInputDialog::getMultiLineText	David Gil (https://codereview.qt-project.org/55905) in Qt 5.2
DONE	QInputDialog should have an equivalent of KInputDialog::getDouble with configurable step. RESULT: it's not really used and adding a step parameter or a new method makes the API ugly. Therefore, I abandon the patch.	David Gil (https://codereview.qt-project.org/54378)
DONE	For better usability, QInputDialog::getItem should use a QListView instead of a QComboBox, like KInputDialog::getItemList. RESULT: Abandoned. Adding another static method to QInputDialog is not needed, since the same result can be achieved with QInputDialog::setOption(QInputDialog::UseListViewForComboBoxItems)	David Gil
DONE	QFileDialog: add the QUrl equivalents of KFileDialog static methods to QFileDialog, should be possible to specify a optional list of protocols supported by the user code	Kevin Ottens (https://codereview.qt-project.org/51031)
DONE	QFileDialog: add QUrl based API for the non-static use of QFileDialog (as mentionned on (https://codereview.qt-project.org/51031)	Kevin Ottens
DONE	Make sure QNetworkAccessManager can list the protocols it supports	Kevin Ottens (https://codereview.qt-project.org/51088)
DONE	Add icons to QLineEdit context menu (via qstyle?)	Aurélien Gâteau (https://codereview.qt-project.org/61221)
DONE	Add icons to QTextBrowser context menu (via qstyle?)	Aurélien Gâteau (https://codereview.qt-project.org/61229)
DONE	Allow to register a default syntax highlighter type for QTextEdit, the KDE backend would register the spell checking one coming from sonnet as default. Change dropped, added a TextEditDecorator class to Sonnet instead	Aurélien Gâteau (https://codereview.qt-project.org/62119)
DONE	Make sure the QPA plugin can properly react to setting changes	Àlex Fiestas
DONE	Restore the getenv+unsetenv _NET_STARTUP_INFO from Qt4 that got lost (work for the xcb backend, next step is using it kdbusservice.cpp)	David Faure (https://codereview.qt-project.org/54499)
DONE	Restore QSessionManager from Qt4 that got broken. David Faure has started some work on this (https://codereview.qt-project.org/61662) https://codereview.qt-project.org/#change,64767	Teo Mrnjavac <[email protected]>
DONE	Extend the QStyle API so that the styleHint() can control the default value for animated widgets (should animate or not by default?)	Àlex Fiestas
DONE	Extend the QStyle API so that the styleHint() can control the default value QSplitter::opaqueResize	Rohan Garg <[email protected]> (https://codereview.qt-project.org/62207)
DONE	Make sure QDialogButtonBox Ok button has Ctrl+Return as shortcut. https://codereview.qt-project.org/59140	[email protected]
DONE	Port features of KPrintDialog to QPrintDialog	Martin Klapetek (in coordination with John Layt and help from Rohan Garg)
DONE	Add a "base" property to QSpinBox	Kevin Ottens, commit 48e3cc30ed in Qt 5.2
DONE	Add MIME Type filtering in QFileDialog	David Faure, commit ee9b9d9fd9 in Qt 5.2
DONE	QLineEdit should control what shortcuts are overriden, such as Ctrl+U and Ctrl+E. See KLineEdit::overrideShortcut	David Edmundson, commit 0b1e30aee in Qt 5.2
DONE	Add Banner Page support to the Job tabs	Martin Klapetek, in Qt 5.2
DONE	Add Page Range support for apps that can't do it themselves (details: http://mail.kde.org/pipermail/kde-frameworks-devel/2013-September/005180.html)	Martin Klapetek, in Qt 5.2
DONE	Add Page Set support (details: http://mail.kde.org/pipermail/kde-frameworks-devel/2013-September/005180.html)	Martin Klapetek, in Qt 5.2
DONE	Make PagesPerSheet and PageSet/PageRange mutually exclusive (details: http://mail.kde.org/pipermail/kde-frameworks-devel/2013-September/005180.html)	Martin Klapetek, in Qt 5.2
DONE	QTimeZone	John Layt, in Qt 5.2

Below are the features which we considered adding to Qt, and ended up solving another way:

Status	Description	Contact
DONE	QLineEdit and QComboBox: support for URL drops (replace existing text, rather than append)	[email protected] (added in a separate class in kwidgetsaddons: LineEditUrlDropEventFilter)
DONE	QTabWidget: give the possibility to hide the tabbar (used in many places if count is 0). Preferably called setTabBarHidden(bool) / isTabBarHidden() (then deprecate ktabwidget). RESULT: Since the exact same functionality can be achieved with tabBar()->hide(bool) and tabBar()->isHidden(), no methods have been added to QTabWidget and both KTabWidget methods have been deprecated.	David Gil
DONE	Make sure QDesktopServices can list the protocols it supports	Kevin Ottens (Turns out it's not even possible to know before hand with xdg-open for a start... It's not really essential anyway: cancelled)
DONE	Add support for default vs active shortcuts to QAction (implemented in KActionCollection instead)	Kevin Ottens
DONE	QLineEdit: support for text squeezing	Kevin Ottens (only one user and half-broken feature anyway, cancelled)
DONE	QIcon: support for overlays (Unacceptable for Qt, ended up in kf5/kguiaddons - https://git.reviewboard.kde.org/r/112079/)	Martin Klapetek
DONE	Implement an equivalent of KPluginFactory for the new plugin system so that one module can contain more than one plugin type and create several instance (done in the kservice framework)	[email protected]
DONE	Use Q_PLUGIN_METADATA instead of KPluginInfo	[email protected]

Note: The qpa is withing staging/frameworkintegration/src/platformtheme