Jump to content

KDE Core/Platform 11/Buildsystem/FindFilesSurvey: Difference between revisions

From KDE Community Wiki
← Older editNewer edit →
Neundorf (talk | contribs)
174 edits
→Other files in kdelibs: Convert table to mediawiki's syntax
Line 467: Line 467:


== Other files in kdelibs ==
== Other files in kdelibs ==
<pre>
{| border="1"
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| File Name
| File Name                         | Plan                                 | Comments                                                           |
| Plan
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Comments
| check_installed_exports_file.cmake | Remove?                               | Alex writes in kdelibs/CMakeLists.txt that the target installation |
|-
|                                    |                                      | code was going to change.                                         |
| check_installed_exports_file.cmake
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Remove?
| kde4_cmake_uninstall.cmake.in     | ?                                     |                                                                    |
| Alex writes in kdelibs/CMakeLists.txt that the target installation code was going to change.
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
|-
| kde4_exec_via_sh.cmake             | ?                                     |                                                                    |
| kde4_cmake_uninstall.cmake.in
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| ?
| kde4automoc.files.in               | Remove once automoc is upstream.     |                                                                    |
|
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
|-
| kde4exportsheader.h.in             | Remove if this feature if upstreamed. |                                                                    |
| kde4_exec_via_sh.cmake
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| ?
| kde4init_dummy.cpp.in             | ?                                    |                                                                    |
|
| kde4init_win32lib_dummy.cpp.in     |                                       |                                                                    |
|-
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| kde4automoc.files.in
| kde4uic.cmake                     | Remove if possible.                   |                                                                    |
| Remove once automoc is upstream.
|------------------------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------|
|
</pre>
|-
| kde4exportsheader.h.in
| Remove if this feature is upstreamed.
|
|-
| kde4init_dummy.cpp.in and kde4init_win32lib_dummy.cpp.in
| ?
|
|-
| kde4uic.cmake
| Remove if possible.
|
|}

Revision as of 15:18, 23 June 2011

Rationale

One of the "coding" tasks consisted of actually going through our Find*.cmake files in kdelibs and its siblings and check what could be removed, upstreamed or merged in the future.

The following tables look not only at the Find files, but also at some helper CMake files which may also cease to exist or move together with their Find counterparts.

kdelibs, kdepimlibs, kde-baseapps, kde-runtime and kde-workspace were analysed.

By the way, these tables were created using Emacs' org-mode, and there was no easy way to convert them to MediaWiki's syntax :)

Check*.cmake files

File Name Exists in CMake Plan Comments Status
CheckCXXSourceCompiles.cmake Yes Search mailing list for CMake developers' rationale, maybe upstream. Began to diverge; CMake has FAIL_REGEX support, our version handles imported targets (Alex said CMake developers did not accept this feature upstream, need to search the mailing list archives).
CheckCXXSourceRuns.cmake Yes Idem. Idem.
CheckCXXSymbolExists.cmake No Either check if we still support glibc 2.9, perhaps try upstreaming. Almost equivalent to CMake's CheckSymbolExists.cmake, just creates .cxx files instead of .c ones.
CheckPointerMember.cmake No Only used by krdc; remove from kdelibs? Calls check_cxx_source_compiles on a struct with a given member.
CheckPrototypeExists.cmake No 1d0e1a0 says this was going to be upstreamed. Try again?
CheckStructMember.cmake No Remove; CMake has CheckStructHasMember.cmake

Find*.cmake

In this table, "upstreaming" a module can mean sending it to either CMake itself or the external modules collection.

kdelibs

|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| File Name                           | Exists in CMake        | Plan                                  | Comments                                       |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindACL.cmake                       | No                     |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindAGG.cmake                       | No                     |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindAlsa.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream without config.h?            |                                                |
| config-alsa.h.cmake                 |                        |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindAkode.cmake                     | No                     | Remove.                               |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindAutomoc4.cmake                  | No                     | Depends on the future of automoc.     |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindAvahi.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindBerkeleyDB.cmake                | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindBlitz.cmake                     | No                     | Remove, already deprecated.           |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindBlueZ.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindBoost.cmake                     | Yes                    | Remove. Already deprecated.           |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindCarbon.cmake                    | No                     | ?                                     |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindDBusMenuQt.cmake                | No                     | Remove in favour of DBMQ providing    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | a Config.cmake file?                  |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindDNSSD.cmake                     | No                     | Merge with FindAvahi.cmake and        |                                                |
|                                     |                        | upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindDocBookXML.cmake                | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindDocBookXSL.cmake                | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindENCHANT.cmake                   | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindEigen.cmake                     | No                     | Remove, already deprecated.           |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindEigen2.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of Eigen providing   |                                                |
|                                     |                        | a Config.cmake file?                  |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindFAM.cmake                       | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindFFmpeg.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindFlac.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindFlex.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindFontconfig.cmake                | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindFreetype.cmake                  | Yes                    | Merge or remove.                      |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGIF.cmake                       | Yes                    | Probably remove.                      |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGLIB2.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGMP.cmake                       | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGObject.cmake                   | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGSSAPI.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGStreamer.cmake                 | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGettext.cmake                   | Yes                    | Merge or provide our macros           | We have some macros used in release tarballs.  |
|                                     |                        | separately.                           |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindGphoto2.cmake                   | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindHUNSPELL.cmake                  | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindHUpnp.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindIOKit.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKDEWorkspace.cmake              | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKDEWIN32.cmake                  | No                     | ?                                     |                                                |
| FindKDEWIN_Packager.cmake           |                        |                                       |                                                |
| FindKDEWin.cmake                    |                        |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKDevPlatform.cmake              | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKNepomuk.cmake                  | No                     | Already deprecated?                   |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKdcraw.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKdeMultimedia.cmake             | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKdepim.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKdepimLibs.cmake                | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKexiv2.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKipi.cmake                      | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKopete.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKorundum.cmake                  | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindKonto.cmake                     | No                     | Already deprecated?                   |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLCMS.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibArt.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibAttica.cmake                 | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibKonq.cmake                   | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibLZMA.cmake                   | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibXml2.cmake                   | Yes                    | Remove.                               | Upstream is pretty much identical.             |
|                                     |                        |                                       | LIBXSLT_XSLTPROC_EXECUTABLE is not used.       |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibXslt.cmake                   | Yes                    | Remove.                               | Upstream is pretty much identical;             |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibintl.cmake                   | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLibraryWithDebug.cmake          | No                     | Upstream to CMake?                    |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindLinuxWirelesstools.cmake        | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindMsgfmt.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindMusicBrainz.cmake               | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindMySQL.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindNepomuk.cmake                   | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindNetworkManager.cmake            | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindOggVorbis.cmake                 | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindOpenEXR.cmake                   | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindOpenSSL.cmake                   | Yes                    | Remove.                               | Upstream is pretty much identical, should even |
|                                     |                        |                                       | solve some reported build issues.              |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPCRE.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPackageHandleStandardArgs.cmake | Yes                    | Long story; let Alex decide.          |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPhonon.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPkgConfig.cmake                 | Yes                    | Remove.                               | Upstream is pretty much identical.             |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPlasma.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPolkitQt-1.cmake                | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPolkitQt.cmake                  | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPopplerQt4.cmake                | No                     | Ask tsdgeos to provide a Config.cmake |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPostgreSQL.cmake                | Yes                    | Probably remove.                      | Upstream looks more complete.                  |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPulseAudio.cmak                 | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPyKDE4.cmake                    | No                     | ?                                     |                                                |
| FindPyKDE4.py                       |                        |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPyQt4.cmake                     | No                     | ?                                     |                                                |
| FindPyQt.py                         |                        |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindPythonLibrary.cmake             | Yes:                   | Try to merge with CMake.              |                                                |
|                                     | FindPythonInterp.cmake |                                       |                                                |
|                                     | FindPythonLibs.cmake   |                                       |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindQCA2.cmake                      | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file?                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindQImageBlitz.cmake               | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindQt4.cmake                       | Yes                    | Probably remove; Alex knows best.     |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindRUBY.cmake                      | Yes (FindRuby.cmake)   | Remove?                               |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSamba.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSane.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSasl2.cmake                     | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSharedDesktopOntologies.cmake   | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSharedMimeInfo.cmake            | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSoprano.cmake                   | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindSqlite.cmake                    | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindStrigi.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file? Strigi is messy.                |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindTaglib.cmake                    | No                     | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake    |                                                |
|                                     |                        | file.                                 |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindUDev.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindUSB.cmake                       | No                     | Rename and upstream?                  |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindWcecompat.cmake                 | No                     | ?                                     |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindX11.cmake                       | Yes                    | Remove.                               |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindXKB.cmake                       | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindXine.cmake                      | No                     | Upstream?                             |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|
| FindXMMS.cmake                      | No                     | Remove as XMMS is dead?               |                                                |
|-------------------------------------+------------------------+---------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------|

kde-baseapps

File Name Exists in CMake Plan Comments Status
FindLibTidy.cmake No Upstream?

kde-runtime

File Name Exists in CMake Plan Comments Status
FindCLucene.cmake No Upstream?
FindLibSSH.cmake No Upstream?
FindQNtrack.cmake No Upstream?
FindSLP.cmake No Upstream?

kde-workspace

|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| File Name               | Exists in CMake | Plan                                     | Comments |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindCkConnector.cmake   | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindDBus.cmake          | No              | Upstream one of the many different       |          |
|                         |                 | copies in the KDE tree.                  |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindGooglegadgets.cmake | No              | Does this still exist? If not, remove.   |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindLibXKlavier.cmake   | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindPAM.cmake           | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindPCIUTILS.cmake      | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindQalculate.cmake     | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindRAW1394.cmake       | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindSensors.cmake       | No              | Rename and upstream?                     |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindOpenGLES.cmake      | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindKephal.cmake        | No              | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake file. |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| Findlibgps.cmake        | No              | Rename and upstream?                     |          |
|-------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|

kdepimlibs

|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| File Name         | Exists in CMake | Plan                                     | Comments |
|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindAkonadi.cmake | No              | Should not be needed if Akonadi starts   |          |
|                   |                 | using Config.cmake files.                |          |
|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindGpgme.cmake   | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindLdap.cmake    | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindLibical.cmake | No              | Upstream?                                |          |
|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|
| FindQgpgme.cmake  | No              | Remove in favour of a Config.cmake file. |          |
|-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+----------|

Framework-specific

In general, they contain KDE-specific code which should not be upstreamed. 

|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| File Name                        | Plan                            | Comments                                              |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| KDE4Defaults.cmake               | -                               |                                                       |
| FindKDE4Internal.cmake           |                                 |                                                       |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| KDE4Macros.cmake                 | -                               | Need to check each macro and see what can be dropped. |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| Qt4ConfigDependentSettings.cmake | Remove our copy                 |                                                       |
| Qt4Macros.cmake                  |                                 |                                                       |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| NepomukAddOntologyClasses.cmake  | Merge into NepomukMacros.cmake? | Need to contact trueg about that.                     |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| NepomukMacros.cmake              | -                               |                                                       |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| PythonCompile.py                 | Upstream?                       |                                                       |
| PythonMacros.cmake               |                                 |                                                       |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| SIPMacros.cmake                  | Upstream?                       |                                                       |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|
| Win32Macros.cmake                | No idea.                        |                                                       |
|----------------------------------+---------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------|

Generic Macros

|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| File Name                             | Exists in CMake | Plan                                     | Comments                  |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroAddCompileFlags.cmake            | No              | Upstream?                                |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroAddLinkFlags.cmake               | No              | Upstream?                                |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroAdditionalCleanFiles.cmake       | No              | Upstream?                                |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroAppendIf.cmake                   | No              | Not used anywhere; remove?               |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroBoolTo01.cmake                   | No              | Upstream?                                |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroEnsureOutOfSourceBuild.cmake     | No              | Remove? People should know they should   |                           |
|                                       |                 | not build in the source directory.       |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroEnsureVersion.cmake              | No              | Upstream?                                |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroKAuth.cmake                      | No              | Remove. Already deprecated.              |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroLibrary.cmake                    | No              | Move functionality to FindKDE4?          |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroLogFeature.cmake                 | No              | Investigate CMake's FeatureSummary.      |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroOptionalAddSubdirectory.cmake    | No              | See outcome of Alex's upstreaming        |                           |
|                                       |                 | efforts.                                 |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroOptionalDependPackage.cmake      | No              | Broken, expects a FindFoo.cmake possibly |                           |
|                                       |                 | provided by the application itself.      |                           |
|                                       |                 | Remove?                                  |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroOptionalFindPackage.cmake        | No              | See outcome of Alex's upstreaming        |                           |
|                                       |                 | efforts.                                 |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroPushRequiredVars.cmake           | No              |                                          | Too specific to upstream? |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|
| MacroWriteBasicCMakeVersionFile.cmake | No              | ?                                        |                           |
|---------------------------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------+---------------------------|

Other files in kdelibs

File Name Plan Comments
check_installed_exports_file.cmake Remove? Alex writes in kdelibs/CMakeLists.txt that the target installation code was going to change.
kde4_cmake_uninstall.cmake.in ?
kde4_exec_via_sh.cmake ?
kde4automoc.files.in Remove once automoc is upstream.
kde4exportsheader.h.in Remove if this feature is upstreamed.
kde4init_dummy.cpp.in and kde4init_win32lib_dummy.cpp.in ?
kde4uic.cmake Remove if possible.
Retrieved from "https://community.kde.org/index.php?title=KDE_Core/Platform_11/Buildsystem/FindFilesSurvey&oldid=13514"