Akademy/2012/Extra Mile BoF: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 13:48, 6 March 2014

The goal of this BoF is to set up an initiative to help KDE applications and workspaces "walk the extra mile": fixing small bugs and UI issues which gets in the way of the user.

KDE products are awesome, but could often be made much more pleasant to use by just ironing out a few quirks here and there.

Similar initiatives have already been run by other Free Software projects:

As far as I know, nothing like this have been done for KDE.

The goal of this BoF is not to start polishing applications right away, but to define the best way to get ourselves organized.

Collecting extramiles

Track them in Bugzilla (either a tag or a tracker bug)
Create an email alias for people who do not want to use bugzilla. Goal is to file bugs for them, not discuss on the alias if it is valid or not.
- David Jarvie
- David Edmundson
- Aurélien Gâteau
- Clemens Toennies
- Thomas Pfeiffer
- Martin Klapetek
- Lasse Liehu
- Kare Sars
- Myriam Schweingruber
Notify the forum admins about it

Criterias to qualify as an "Extra Mile Bug" (EMB)

Is a bug or an enhancement, not a feature request
Affects many users
Makes using the application harder or less pleasant
Easy to fix

How to determine a bug is easy to fix

A bug is easy to fix if it can be fixed in one day by one person.

Maintainer should be able to help deciding if it can be fixed this way. If it cannot the bug can stay but it should not be marked as extramile anymore.

Communication

Use the mailing list of the KDE Quality team (kde-testing@) to discuss extra miles.
IRC channel: #kde-quality
Mail on kde-devel, kde-testing and blog every two weeks
Testdays: to be decided later, if we feel there is a need for them
Quantitative goals: not for now, we will see later

Actions

[Jeroen van Meeuwen] Setup the bugzilla mediawiki extension
[Aurélien Gâteau] Mail the bugsquad ML to announce the extramile initiative
[Aurélien Gâteau] Create an alias email [email protected]

@@ Line 13: / Line 13: @@
 The goal of this BoF is not to start polishing applications right away, but to define the best way to get ourselves organized.
-== Topics to discuss ==
+== Collecting extramiles ==
-* Come up with a set of criterias a bug must meet to qualify as an "Extra Mile Bug" (EMB). Possible criterias:
-** Affects many users
+* Track them in Bugzilla (either a tag or a tracker bug)
-** Makes using the application harder or less pleasant
+* Create an email alias for people who do not want to use bugzilla. Goal is to file bugs for them, not discuss on the alias if it is valid or not.
-** Easy to fix
+** David Jarvie
-* How to track EMBs. We can:
+** David Edmundson
-** Use bug reports with an EMB tag
+** Aurélien Gâteau
-** Create a "tracker" bug, which all EMB reports should depend on
+** Clemens Toennies
-** List EMB on a wikipage
+** Thomas Pfeiffer
-* How to report progress, and how often. We can:
+** Martin Klapetek
-** Create a new mailing list
+** Lasse Liehu
-** Post progress on existing lists like kde-devel
+** Kare Sars
-** Write blog posts
+** Myriam Schweingruber
-* Should we create a #kde-extramile IRC channel?
+* Notify the forum admins about it
-* Should we organize test days like the "Fit and Finish" initiative did?
-* Should we define a quantitative goal like the "Papercut" project did (100 papercuts fixed every 6 months)
+== Criterias to qualify as an "Extra Mile Bug" (EMB) ==
+* Is a bug or an enhancement, not a feature request
+* Affects many users
+* Makes using the application harder or less pleasant
+* Easy to fix
+=== How to determine a bug is easy to fix ===
+A bug is easy to fix if it can be fixed in one day by one person.
+Maintainer should be able to help deciding if it can be fixed this way. If it cannot the bug can stay but it should not be marked as extramile anymore.
+== Communication ==
+* Use the mailing list of the KDE Quality team (kde-testing@) to discuss extra miles.
+* IRC channel: #kde-quality
+* Mail on kde-devel, kde-testing and blog every two weeks
+* Testdays: to be decided later, if we feel there is a need for them
+* Quantitative goals: not for now, we will see later
 == Actions ==
+* [Jeroen van Meeuwen] Setup the bugzilla mediawiki extension
+* [Aurélien Gâteau] Mail the bugsquad ML to announce the extramile initiative
+* [Aurélien Gâteau] Create an alias email [email protected]